Homeowners Insurance Services

- In Business Since 1983
- Free Quotes Available
- Competitive Rates

This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.

Get Protection From the Big Companies

When you choose us, you'll get the personal attention and customer service of our small, family owned firm, while being backed by powerful policies from some of the insurance industry's most trusted names.

Reach out to us today for policies from big companies like West Bend, Acuity, Badger Mutual, ASI, and more - all at competitive prices. Call today to see what you could save! Don't worry about the paperwork, we'll take care of it. We are PIA certified.

Trust Our Experience

We've been getting our customers coverage at great rates since 1983. Trust Tamer Insurance Agency to have the connections it takes to get the best possible deal for you and your home!

Our staff periodically undergoes courses and seminars to stay up-to-date with the market trends and maintain our certificates.

Meet Our Partners

  • West Bend 
  • Acuity 
  • Badger Mutual 
  • Progressive - snapshot program 

Your One-Stop Shop for Homeowner's Insurance

You can count on us to assist you with the following:
  • Homeowner's insurance 
  • Renter's insurance 
  • Mobile homes 
  • Condos 
  • Dwelling fire insurance 
  • Collectibles insurance 
  • Scheduled jewelry 
  • Personal property insurance 
  • Flood insurance and more!

Get Great Insurance Deals for Your Home

Call us today for a FREE quote.

(414) 476-0700

(414) 476-0700
hibu-tm

My husband and I have benefited so much from working with Tamer Insurance Agency. As a young couple, navigating insurance policies is still new and confusing, but Tamer always helps us understand and find the best coverage for our needs. I want to give a special shout-out to Sandy at Tamer who uncovered a way to discount our policy payment in half while maintaining the same level of coverage - her skills, advocacy, and commitment to her clients make her a real life superhero. Thank you, Sandy!

- Kelsey Porada

Learn More About

Tamer Insurance Agency

Play Video